Discuss Safety Drop Test in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bernie2

I was "Googling" the other day out of interest to find out if there is much information on how to do a domestic safety gas drop test.

Surprisingly I found very little.

I thought it seems the next step is not tell drivers what the centre pedal is for in their cars.

Old hands will tell you people can't always rely on smelling gas, to find they have a leak, but they should know how drop tests are conducted even if they don't or can't do it themselves. That way they can ask for one to be done.

Just seems a bit soft not to have this safety information freely available.
 
my mother has no knowledge of a boiler but she too would instantly go mad if it was upside down or falling off the wall

When we were born and throughtout lives were are given the human nature and gut feelings and instincts that grow as we do. we get those hunchs that something isn't right and it is our decision whether to act on this or not.

I, under no circumstances wish to imply that someone who is a professional is perfect, no one is perfect (accept Shakira!) but I beleive being a professional means you have a skill level but obvisouly these skill levels cannot be measured, yes so and so plumber can have NVQ levels higher than that plumber but that means he was good with an exam and a a folder of work and good in a controlled environment.

Gas fitting info is not need by the public, they are required to rely on the services of a 'professional' (albeit i use the term loosely). we are in the day and age that we leave the pro to it and raise the issue after if we are not happy. I have learned my trade over the years and worked hard at it. I dont want to go around telling people how to do this and that as I will lose money. I still appreciate the call out to a dripping tap and whilst any competent person could go on the internet and find out how to fix it they dont and they call in someone and pay as they want it done porperly. Even if joe public was to be told how a drop test should be carried out who should tell them this. One gas fitter who has learnt it years ago through the trade, a tutor, a recenlty qualified gas fitter, all who will have different tools methods and preferences. and even if shown then joe public will need to do it themselves a few times to fully understand so I cant see it working.

If someone wants to know how i fixed their lack of hitting by just banging a spanner on a pipe then go and find out, I am not a tutor, i get paid for fixing stuff not teaching stuff.

I enjoy this conversation and hope that I cause no offense i do look at your side of the court room and look to give an understanding, plus a healthy debate is good for ones self.
 
Its probably GaSafes and the HSE's job to tell people about things related to their safety.

Lets be honest a gas fitter doing a 12 month gas check and that applies to tenanted property only not private, private may never have had a gas test done at all at anytime, is not enough. Suppose a problem develops between tests?

How are people to recognise one if they know nothing about gas testing?

Smelling gas? Not very likely in a big house and you can't smell carbon monoxide.

So a house owner knowing how and why a gas test should be done would seem a good thing.

Lets be honest, it doesn't follow that just because somebody knows about your job they are going to put you out of work all of a sudden.

A doctor will usually tell you all about what is wrong with you, my own doctors in the past have even explained and shown me pictures of what my balance problem is.

But no way am I going to open up as a doctor tomorrow.

What I think has happened in the gas industry, is that the info sellers have been allowed to get away with all kinds. A gas training course is now part of a vast training industry, which going by the costs of the courses must be making a packet.

Even a basic gas book is something ridiculous like £90.

This is also possibly linked to the point that there are not many living wage jobs about that people can get into, except the likes of gas fitting.

So if you have spent thousands on a course, you may feel its not fair for people to be getting the information they gave you on the course for free and so perhaps not require your services.

Not only that, by handing over thousands you would probably feel you had been taken for a ride by the trainers.

But if you consider that the gas industry flourished for what must be 150 years or more without any sort of compulsory training courses, it may be goes to show, info can be made free without putting people out of work.

The industry itself is dripping with cash. The big players make profits perhaps running into billions yet its the gas fitter through training costs and the customer through installation, repair and fuels costs, that makes those profits possible get the rough end of things it seems.

When BG was nationalised, as a Plumbing tutor I could ring them up or send a letter and get for gratis virtually any sort of gas information I wanted.

Today I would probably have to take a mortgage out to get info about how to do a basic drop test. That is part of what is wrong with the industry.

Gas fitters should be able to show anybody who wants to know, what they are doing, providing its on safety grounds, so they can make sure its done properly.

Incidentally, I was once told that CORGI when it was in charge, had its work cut out trying to sort problems out between gas fitters and their customers, in point perhaps to many of their staff where appointed to dispute and problem solving rather than looking after customers interests, which wasn't really CORGI's job.

GaSafe is intended to work for both sides. But it does seem to show trained or not gas fitters, like everybody else can make mistakes. The thing is perhaps we should give the customer more info to base their idea about whether a mistake has been made or not? Seems fair.

Lets not be afraid of loosing work instead of promoting safety they do not compare.
 
Even a basic gas book is something ridiculous like £90.

...

Today I would probably have to take a mortgage out to get info about how to do a basic drop test. That is part of what is wrong with the industry.

I think we are exaggerating just a wee bit, no? CORGI Essential Gas Safety, Domestic between £18-25, NICEIC Domestic Gas Safety (plus appliances) £45, both of which tell you how to do a tightness test.
 
Is telling some one how to do a gas tightness test and repeating manufacturers instructions that come free with most appliances really worth £45 even?

Lets be honest most books are based on BS standards stuff or Gas Engineering manuals. It's all copied. A £10 should be tops for any book info to cover hard copy costs and preferably free as downloads on the Internet.

On the US sites they tell you virtually anything you want to know about anything for free.

How come over here we seem to say "How much can I make out of this info" all the time?

That is not true of course, our electrical cousins whose job is perhaps just as dangerous as ours, have a website called Voltimum, which tells you virtually anything you want to know about electrical testing or installation.

So if it doesn't bother "sparks" why should it bother gas fitters?

I admit training course providers do need to make an income but that should really be paid for by the section of the industry that makes the most out of the industry, that seems fair.
 
Why don't you Post the steps on here with the drops for type of meter time for let by and so on then the public can have a read. But remember it will have your name on it so if someone did have a go and messed up and lived to tell the tail it could all come back to u.
Transco " so why were y doing a drop test ?"
joe " I was Reading on line when I found how to do it.
I didn't think it was against the law because if it was they wouldn't explained how to do it. "
 
That is silly Macplumb and it is not what I said.

You can't get into trouble for giving advice on a forum, especially safety information, its entirely at the readers discretion whether they follow it or not anyway.

Next thing you will be telling me, is that doctors all over the world are being arrested for giving medical advice on the internet and the government has closed down the NHS Direct internet site for giving advice.

Look at things this way then:

If a DIYer wants do a job they think they are competent to do, how are you going to stop them doing it?

Incidentally it is not against the law to do gas work in your own home if you are competent to do so. What constitutes competency has yet to be tested in the courts.

So a DIYer doing work in their own home, may very well think they know enough, to consider themselves competent. In reality they may know little about the job.

You can't say "You don't know how to do that?" they think they can. And I suppose, they are hardly likely to ask your permission to do the work, they may not even know you.

But if they happen to live next door to you and your family and a system they have installed incorrectly goes BANG what do you do?

Sue them?

But by then your family may be splattered all over the neighbourhood.

So which would you prefer?

A DIYer to do a job you can't stop them doing, doing it more safely or a DIYer doing a job any old way they think is safe?

Either way its your choice, I know which I would prefer.

Then suppose there was a gas explosion and the HSE investigated and found you knew the right way to do things, the DIYer had asked you and you had refused to tell them the dangers or proper procedures required, for reasons of your own.

Being a gas fitter you are probably classed as a responsible person and so not to give advice when asked, may be considered irresponsible and a good safety lawyer would probably have you in pieces in minutes.

Giving correct and full advice does not constitute any support for the listeners later actions of course.

There are probably plenty of people who could tell you how to fire a gun, but is it their fault if you shoot somebody?

Lets be more human please. DIYers do not intentionally go out to do bad jobs, I find its quite the reverse usually. Its usually through a lack of knowledge they get them wrong.

Another aspect is: If you knew what the DIYer was doing and reported them to the gas supplier, like you should if you think there is a suspected dangerous installation.

Now suppose the gas supplier found the DIYers installation to be correct and all standards followed. They can't refuse to supply the gas, because it proves the DIYer was competent by the standard of the work done.

Perhaps the DIYer may sue you instead, for bringing him or her into disrepute by suggesting they where jeopardising peoples safety?

Things are often not as simple as they seem.

Anything that may improve safety is a positive not a negative, whether that thing is information or not and most people respond if they know the reason why things are done, rather than told not to do it without an explanation.

As an add if you can't give them information on gas drops then it follws you should not be able to on gas boilers or unvented systems. That doesn't leave much to talk about on the forum does it, if you consider how many boiler questions we get. What about if Plumbers are required to be registered to work with water?

Will we have a forum full of blank mails?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You guys are weird and dangerous!

The next you will be saying, is that only registered GaSafe engineers should light cooker hobs or alter the regulo setting on cooker ovens.

But you give me a good laugh anyway :) :)

You young guys!!!!
 
Bernie, its 'Gas Safe' NOT 'GaSafe', which is very annoying when your banging on about the gas industry/gas engineers and you cant even get the name right.
 
knowledge is a product though and a product is worth an amount

If I knew how to make a new renewable energy not thought of do you think for one minute i would give this information out for free, I would patent and maybe then sell it to the highest bidder or look at the route of developing it myself

Information has always cost money and always will, yes if you know where to look you can get some bits for free, but if you want it offiaical and from a trustworthy source then get your wallet out.

________

I dont thnink Bernie has lost the plot I just think this is a valid debate and he has taken one side which is the minority, nothing saying he is wrong and I/We are right
 
Last edited:
Hi! Mark

You are correct it is Gas Safe not GaSafe, I got that I think from an old logo of theirs. I did know the scheme is called Gas Safe.

By the way it is okay to disagree you know. Perhaps I do come at things from a minority angle, probably having been a Plumbing tutor for a while as well as a registered Plumber /gas fitter servicing thousands of houses, it perhaps gives you a different perspective.

Extensive gas Fitting knowledge by the way, is widely held by many other people other than ACS registered gas fitters. And having that knowledge they don't usually
go around doing DIY gas fitting in their own home. Even though its not against the law for them to do so.

The said reason is that they are not stupid, they know how onerous it is on the individual if they do.

Its not having gas fitting knowledge that stops them doing paid cowboy work either, its the law.

So possessing gas fitting knowledge by itself is not dangerous, it would appear its a good safety feature acting as a deterrent, for knowing the dangers and who the legal onus is on, many don't do it for those very reasons.

If they had no knowledge of how things are done they may very well just think its simple and have a go. After all is that not what most DIYers and cowboys do?

The question to ask perhaps is "Would they do it if they knew what was involved in the job?"

The answer as far as I am aware is No!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
im laughing at the secretacy of this magical tightness test,
1min Let by Test at 10 mb
1min temperature stabilisation at 20mb
2min tightness test
OOOPS did i just spill the beans

but anyway, u cant do it without being on the gas safe register
and like someone said if you got any trouble there is the grid number
0800 111 999 i think off the top of my head.

Peace Guys!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Reply to Safety Drop Test in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Newest Plumbing Threads

Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock