Search the forum,

Discuss Thermal store nightmare in the Oil and Solid Fuel Forum area at PlumbersForums.net

Messages
10
Sorry for a long post but we have a complicated thermal store situation

Over the summer we had a new solid fuel stovax back boiler installed and upgraded our hot water storage tank to a thermal store.

We have not had reliable hot water since. Initially we only used the emersion and after couple of hours we could run a shallow bath.

Now we can run a bath when the fire is on but even the morning after the fire has been on we can only get a small amount of water. If left to run more than a couple of mins the water soon cools down. If left we can then get another bout of hot water 2p mins or so later.

The engineer is completely stumped. We have replaced the mixer, the tank has been tested and is up to temperature. We have insulated all the pipes to ensure minimal heat loss.

The engineer thinks that perhaps the mixer valve is again faulty but the hot water pipe leaving the tank before the mixer does not feel overly warm.

I'm pretty convinced there must be a fault with the copper heat exchange coil. Maybe small holes with water leaking out or some reason for inefficient heat exchange. The engineer seems confident this isn't the case as we get good hot water when the fire is on.

In summary low volume and short bursts of demands on the store does not seem to be a problem (ie when the water has been sat in the coil for a length of time) but any higher volume demand, the water is soon cold. The tank itself seems to cool pretty quickly too.

It's gone on so long I'm thinking about getting rid of the thermal store and reinstalling the header tank to go back to a conventional system
 
Last edited:
Is it only the stove feeding the thermal store, if so I wouldn't have gone with a thermal store.
But then I'm not a big fan of thermal stores.

Has it been installed correctly?

Any pics of the install?
 
It is just the stove and an emersion heater.
The install I think is ok. There are preexisting 15mm pipes under the bathroom floor from the fire to the store (just a short stretch otherwise its 30mm throughout) the thermal store does seem to heat up quickly and gets very hot so we had ruled this out as a possibility.
 

Attachments

  • 15788380613225827053710470874373.jpg
    15788380613225827053710470874373.jpg
    78.6 KB · Views: 32
Sorry for a long post but we have a complicated thermal store situation

Over the summer we had a new solid fuel stovax back boiler installed and upgraded our hot water storage tank to a thermal store.

We have not had reliable hot water since. Initially we only used the emersion and after couple of hours we could run a shallow bath.

Now we can run a bath when the fire is on but even the morning after the fire has been on we can only get a small amount of water. If left to run more than a couple of mins the water soon cools down. If left we can then get another bout of hot water 2p mins or so later.

The engineer is completely stumped. We have replaced the mixer, the tank has been tested and is up to temperature. We have insulated all the pipes to ensure minimal heat loss.

The engineer thinks that perhaps the mixer valve is again faulty but the hot water pipe leaving the tank before the mixer does not feel overly warm.

I'm pretty convinced there must be a fault with the copper heat exchange coil. Maybe small holes with water leaking out or some reason for inefficient heat exchange. The engineer seems confident this isn't the case as we get good hot water when the fire is on.

In summary low volume and short bursts of demands on the store does not seem to be a problem (ie when the water has been sat in the coil for a length of time) but any higher volume demand, the water is soon cold. The tank itself seems to cool pretty quickly too.

It's gone on so long I'm thinking about getting rid of the thermal store and reinstalling the header tank to go back to a conventional system
In order to get the correct info. you will need to explain a few things
1. which Stovax by model
2. Which thermal store
3. maybe a diagram of what it was ...and how it is now.
I like conventional systems but others on PF will have their views, especially as you have already forked out ....let us know...loads of collective knowlege on PF ...Centralheatking
 
As above, plus how long is the Stovax back boiler fire up, what fuel and what level of burn
e.g a couple logs cracking for a few hours or coal blazing away all day and evening long.

When the tank temperature was tested how was that done, just observing a guage at the top or ?

Who recommended the Thermal store, who designed the system?
 
Thank you so much for your help. I'm not sure on the name of the thermal store, I am getting that info as we speak. It has a copper coil that much I do know. It is a stovax 8hb we burn coal and wood.
I've attached my understanding of the system. (Not an artist, and I hope it is the info you need)
[automerge]1578843639[/automerge]
As above, plus how long is the Stovax back boiler fire up, what fuel and what level of burn
e.g a couple logs cracking for a few hours or coal blazing away all day and evening long.

When the tank temperature was tested how was that done, just observing a guage at the top or ?

Who recommended the Thermal store, who designed the system?

We mainly have coal blazing from about 5 until we go to bed about 11 and top it up before we go upstairs. We occasionally add a couple of logs if we have it burning longer on a cold day.
I'm not sure how he tested the temperature but there is no inbuilt temperature gauge. The system was in place when we moved in and we have just replaced the stove out of necessity and was recommended the thermal store by the heating engineer (heatas registered)
[automerge]1578848875[/automerge]
Also we have had the emersion and the fire on for several evenings in succession and the emersion turns off as it is up to temperature. Still the water is not hot in the morning
 

Attachments

  • 15788405336675144823647759738055.jpg
    15788405336675144823647759738055.jpg
    94.8 KB · Views: 37
  • 20200112_143754.jpg
    20200112_143754.jpg
    74.6 KB · Views: 27
Last edited:
For a Stovax HB, the only inputs you as a user can have to increase Hot Water Temperature / volume is the fuel (not enough or wrong type) and air control settings. Anything else is a design / sizing / installation issue - so I would get the installer back.

Most of the Stovax range ( other than the 14kw models) need to have the fire to be fully stacked most of the time to achieve the stated outputs. As the fire burns down, the contact area with the back boiler reduces - along with the output.

If you have any doubts about the fuel, run it for a week on anthracite - keeping it fully loaded - you won’t get an output any better than that.
 
Could it be cold water is getting into the systems somewhere?

If your mains cold was getting into store there would most likely be a split in coil and the system header tank would be discharging through overflow.
 
I had not seen your system diagram before I wrote my earlier post - my posts are delayed / moderated.

No point experimenting with anthracite or air settings.

You need to get your installer back - or engage with Stovax direct who will give you the correct schematic for your scheme and thermal store specification ( albeit you don’t really need a thermal store for a single source installation).

As you will note from the above, assuming your sketch is correct, the installation is wrong (and probably not correctly sized).

Not really what you want to hear I am afraid.
 
Last edited:
Seems to be no heat leak rads on your system?
(I was thinking that was a possible heat loss if a heat leak rad was piped to store wrongly).
Also wondering about the circulating pump doing the rad circuit. Is it properly controlled and switching off?
 
I had not seen your system diagram before I wrote my earlier post - my posts are delayed / moderated.

No point experimenting with anthracite or air settings.

You need to get your installer back - or engage with Stovax direct who will give you the correct schematic for your scheme and thermal store specification ( albeit you don’t really need a thermal store for a single source installation).

As you will note from the above, assuming your sketch is correct, the installation is wrong (and probably not correctly sized).

Not really what you want to hear I am afraid.
Thank you
Does it look way off the mark? You have gotten me worried!
Having a look on the stovax info, non of the examples have a separate hot water and heating circuit? Is that an issue.
We decided on a thermal store for various reasons. Mains pressure hot water. Hot water supplied to our third floor en suite planned in the future. We are also hopeful to get some solar panels or perhaps gas/oil boiler (we are off grid) who knows when but thought best to future proof. Starting to regret it now
 
If you talk to Stovax and send them the sketches you have posted here, they will send you a schematic of how it should be laid out and the correct specification for the thermal store. The 15mm pipe restrictions (on the primary), if I have read that correctly in your post, are also not acceptable for your stove.

On the positive side, the stove can be configured for hot water only. When properly installed (with a correctly sized thermal store) if you need it ( the store) for the addition of a future heat source the stove will deliver copious quantities of hot water when fuelled with coal or kiln dried logs
 
Last edited:
OP has probably moved on since it looks like an account just created for this issue, so I am not sure if I should comment, but I do have an interest in thermal stores.

In the diagram it looks like a vented cylinder was swapped for a thermal store. Since it was in the same place, I wonder how big the store is (same size?). I would roughly estimate that a thermal store needs to be at least twice the size of a vented or unvented cylinder to get the same performance, without significant heat input while running the hot water. This is if the store is kept quite hot. As the temperature reduces, say to 65C or so, you would need to have it around 3x the size, however in many stores the DHW coil is too small to work well at lower temperatures, unless it is specifically designed for that.
 
I have just reread your early post. I think you state that the fire boiler is connect to the thermal store in 15mm. If this is correct - that is your problem. It needs to be 28mm on the flow. Look at the Stovax installation manual
 

Reply to Thermal store nightmare in the Oil and Solid Fuel Forum area at PlumbersForums.net

Creating content since 2001. Untold Media.

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock